data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bfe83/bfe83831af20328665e4ce413aae102e49ec79d2" alt=""
By Steve Lowrie, CFA
Special to Financial Independence Hub
A key concern many investors have at the moment is the impact of Trump’s tariffs on goods produced outside the U.S. on the markets. I’m hearing from those wondering if they should do something to protect their wealth; their primary question is: What should I do with my investments?
My answer (as it usually is when investors are concerned about the geopolitical impact on the markets): stick with the plan because, by the time the news is public and you become concerned, the markets have already accounted for it/priced it in, so any reaction you take is too late.
A useful historical reference on tariffs is President Trump’s first term. Starting in 2017, his administration targeted China, implementing tariffs on a broad range of products by 2018. The following years saw ongoing trade negotiations that led to an agreement, though many tariffs remained. Despite the uncertainty, both U.S. and Chinese markets outperformed the MSCI World ex USA Index over Trump’s four-year term. Have a look at the data from 2017 to 2020, as Dimensional compares China MSCI Index to US S&P 500 Index to MSCI World ex USA Index.
Markets are forward-looking, meaning that the potential economic effects of tariffs are likely already factored into current prices. As a result, when these anticipated changes materialize, their impact on markets may be limited.
Understanding how Market Pricing Works
Let’s talk about the price of stocks.
It stands to reason: To make money in the market, you need to sell your holdings for more than you paid. Of course, we’re all familiar with good old “buy low, sell high.” But despite its simplicity, many investors fall short. Instead, they end up doing just the opposite, or at least leaving returns on the table that could have been theirs to keep.
You can defend against these human foibles by understanding how stock pricing works and using that knowledge to your advantage.
Good News, Bad News, and Market Views
How do you know when a stock or stock fund is priced for buying or selling?
The short answer is, we don’t.
And yet, many investors still let current events dominate their decisions. They sell when they fear bad news means prices are going to fall. Or they buy when good news breaks. They invest in funds that do the same.
While this may seem logical, there’s a problem with it: You’re betting you or your fund manager can place winning trades before markets have already priced in the news.
To be blunt, that’s a losing bet.
You’re betting that you know more about what the price should be at any given point than what the formidable force of the market has already decided. Every so often, you might be right. But the preponderance of the evidence suggests any “wins” are more a matter of luck than skill.
Me and You against the World
Whenever you try to buy low or sell high, who is the force on the other side of the trading table?
It’s the market.
The market includes millions of individuals, institutions, banks, and brokerages trading hundreds of billions of dollars every moment of every day. It includes highly paid analysts continuously watching every move the markets make. It includes AI-driven engines seeking to get their trades in nanoseconds ahead of everyone else.
And you think you can beat that?
We believe it’s far more reasonable to assume, by the time you’ve heard the news, the collective market has too, and has already priced it in.
- News of a recession, under way or avoided? It’s already priced in.
- Inflation on the rise, or abating? It’s already priced in.
- A company suffers a calamity or makes a major breakthrough? It’s already priced in.
- The government passes critical legislation that helps or hinders global trading? It’s…
And so on. Here’s your best assumption:
If it’s public knowledge, it’s already priced in. (And if it’s insider information, it’s illegal to trade on it.)
What we don’t yet Know
As soon as an event is priced in, several things make it difficult to profitably trade on the news:
You’re Buying High, Selling Low: If you trade on news after it’s been priced in, odds are you’ll buy at a higher price (after good news) or sell at a lower price (based on bad news). Continue Reading…