Posted By 
By Andy Atchison, FairRate Canada
(Special to Financial Independence Hub)
Getting a mortgage renewal letter seems pretty straightforward. Your lender gives you a new rate and payment, you sign it, and you’re done.
At least that’s how it looks.
What I started wondering was: how does the average homeowner actually know if the offer they’re getting is any good?
I’m not a mortgage broker or financial adviser. I’m just someone who started digging into this and realized it’s surprisingly difficult to get a simple answer. You can search mortgage rates online in about 30 seconds. The problem is that the rate you find isn’t necessarily comparable to the renewal offer sitting in front of you.
There can be different conditions, different mortgage types, different equity requirements and all sorts of other details attached to an advertised rate. So if your bank offers you 4.89% and you find 4.24% online, that doesn’t automatically mean your bank is ripping you off.
But I’d certainly want to know why there’s a difference.
The rate is a starting point
Obviously the interest rate matters.
A difference that looks fairly small on paper can make a noticeable difference to your payment, especially with a large mortgage balance.
But there are other things worth looking at too.
What are the prepayment privileges? What happens if you need to break the mortgage early? Is it portable? Are there fees or restrictions? And if another lender has a lower rate, what would it actually cost and involve to move the mortgage?
Those details aren’t nearly as exciting as finding a lower rate, but they can matter.
There’s nothing wrong with staying with your bank
I think this part sometimes gets lost.
Switching lenders isn’t automatically the smart move.
If your current lender gives you a reasonable offer, staying put may be easier. There can be real value in avoiding extra paperwork, appraisals, legal costs or another qualification process.
I’d just want that to be a decision rather than the default because a renewal form showed up in the mail.
Before signing, I’d ask the lender a few questions.
Is this the best rate you can offer me?
Are there other options available?
What happens if I want to make extra payments?
How are penalties calculated?
Are there any restrictions I should know about?
You don’t need to know the mortgage business inside and out to ask those questions.
Advertised rates are only part of the picture
One thing I’ve learned while building FairRate Canada is that advertised mortgage rates and actual renewal offers are two different things.
An existing customer may be offered something better than a lender’s posted rate. Another customer may get something different again.
That makes it hard for a homeowner to look at one rate online and know where their own offer really stands.
It’s one of the reasons I built FairRate Canada at fairratecanada.ca.
For supported five-year fixed renewals, the free checker compares the offer someone received with current public market context. It doesn’t tell them whether to sign, switch lenders or reject the offer.
It just gives them some context they didn’t have before.
I’m also working on something called the Mortgage Renewal Offer Index. The idea is to collect anonymous information about the renewal offers Canadians are actually receiving.
I think that could eventually be more useful than looking only at advertised rates because it starts answering a different question: what are lenders actually offering people when their mortgages come up for renewal?
It’s still very early. I won’t publish headline results until there are at least 25 valid submissions, and even after that it needs to be treated for what it is: a voluntary sample, not a survey of every Canadian homeowner.
Take a few minutes before signing
I don’t think homeowners need to turn themselves into mortgage experts every five years.
But a mortgage is a big enough expense that spending a little time understanding the renewal offer seems worthwhile.
Look at the rate. Look at the terms. Ask your lender some questions. See what alternatives actually exist.
You might end up signing the exact same renewal offer.
The difference is that you’ll have a better idea of what you’re signing and why.
Andy Atchison lives in Edmonton, Alberta, and is the founder of FairRate Canada, an independent Canadian resource designed to help homeowners better understand mortgage renewal offers and compare them with current market context. FairRate’s free renewal checker gives homeowners an independent point of reference before they sign, without sales pressure or requiring personal information. Learn more at https://www.fairratecanada.ca.
