Special to the Financial Independence Hub
The Liberal Government has stated it wants to build a strong middle class, but who comprises the middle class? Mr. Morneau in his 2017 budget speech stated, “All Canadians must pay their fair share of taxes,” but what is a “fair share”? Does fair share mean the total amount of taxes one pays as a percentage of their gross income? Is this based on an annual consideration or a lifetime consideration? Or does fair share mean positively contributing to the general revenue?
The answer to the first question is an ongoing contentious debate. According to former Finance Minister Mr. Joe Oliver, the middle class could include households earning as much as $120,000. Given research completed by MoneySense Magazine[1], the middle class could include households earning incomes ranging from $38,800 to $125,000 (average second, third, and fourth quintiles for Canadian households), but this varies considerably between Provinces and Territories, and even between cities. But does owning a private corporation automatically exclude you from the middle class? The continued witch hunt on private corporations by the Liberal Government would indicate this is the case since it directly contradicts their mandate to build a strong middle class.
Comparing a private-sector and public-sector worker
It is at this time I would like to introduce Sally. Sally could be a physician or accountant, an engineer or architect, a therapist or life coach, or a hairstylist or clothing retailer. Suffice to say that either out of choice or necessity, she is self employed. Let’s make her a plumber who is in a position where it makes sense for her to incorporate because she can defer income within her corporation and income split with her spouse under present tax legislation. Her spouse works part-time. Their situation can be summarized as follows:
- Sally’s taxable corporate income: $100,000
- Spouse’s gross income: $25,000
- Net income required to meet their lifestyle: $80,000
- Spouse’s CPP income: $4,300






