By Jeff Weniger, CFA, WisdomTree Investments
Special to the Financial Independence Hub
The 24-year-old North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has never been this close to death, but a resolution could be behind the storm clouds.
Souring trade relations with the U.S. are a shame, because Canada got caught in the wrong place at the wrong time. Consider figure 1. President Donald Trump wants to make a dent in the US$388 billion annual trade deficit with China and, to a lesser extent, the yawning gaps with Mexico, Germany and Japan. But to show strength to them economically and North Korea militarily, he believes he has to treat even friendly actors such as Japan and Canada like hostile players. That became apparent when the U.S. administration imposed global steel and aluminum tariffs, and Canada wasn’t exempted.
Figure 1: Monthly U.S. Trade Deficit/Surplus (USD in Millions)
Talks are starting to get personal, with U.S. President Donald Trump accusing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of making false statements at a June news conference after G7 leaders met amicably. The Canadian leader then got relatively tough, responding that “Canadians … will not be pushed around.”
With the world’s two best friends in a lovers’ quarrel, the US$13 billion annual U.S.-Canadian trade gap, a rounding error, is somehow a political issue. It could have been resolved over golf.
But not all is lost. Ottawa would be wise to consider — if it is legal — scrapping NAFTA for a bilateral trade agreement with Washington.
Canada ill-advised to sit at table with Mexico
That’s because Canada is ill-advised to sit at the table with Mexico to try to strongarm the U.S. Not now, in 2018, given Mexico’s own specific troubles. Frankly, Mexico’s negotiating calculus is much weaker than Canada’s. The country went to the polls July 1, and leftist Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO) won. He won’t help Canada one bit because it isn’t politically palpable for him to shoot for a quick resolution. Hostility to the U.S. — or at least standing ground against Washington — has been a political winner for the Latin American “pink tide”1 for years. Playing the tough-talk game with Trump will be one of AMLO’s key rallying cries, and it can only cripple NAFTA. Continue Reading…








