
By Noah Solomon
Special to Financial Independence Hub
Same old story, same old song
Goes all right till it goes all wrong
Now you`re going, then you`re gone
Same old story, same old song
— B. B. King
Voting Over the Short-Term vs. Weighing Over the Long-Term
Famed investor Benjamin Graham, widely known as the father of value investing and (Warren) Buffett’s mentor, said “In the short run, the market is a voting machine but in the long run, it is a weighing machine.” Graham’s statement captures the very essence of market behaviour since time immemorial.
Over the course of any month, quarter, year, or several years, there are any number of factors that can influence the returns of any single stock, sector, or asset class. Whereas these factors are numerous, the main “culprits” are usually behavioural in nature. Greed and fear, panic and euphoria, herd mentalities, and other emotional biases have historically been the key drivers of short- to medium-term movements in security prices.
Importantly, these forces can become sufficiently extreme as to cause prices to become largely disassociated from fundamentally justifiable levels. Looking at past bubbles (and subsequent collapses), the stories are remarkably similar. The Dutch Tulip Mania of the mid 1600s, the South Sea Bubble of the early 1700s, the roaring 1920s, and the dotcom bubble of the late 1990s were all spurred by euphoria, herding, fear of missing out (FOMO) and “it can only go up” mentality which ended in tears and losses. On the flipside, the subsequent loss of confidence and despondency eventually set the stage for above-average gains over the ensuing several years.
The (not so) Simple Keys to Successful Investing
Fundamental valuations, which lie at the heart of Graham’s long-term weighing machine, are the “anchor” of equilibrium prices that foreshadow neither higher- nor lower-than-average returns (or losses). Historically, whenever valuations have stood well above their long-term averages, returns over the next several years have tended to fall in the range of disappointing to outright painful. Conversely, when valuations have stood well below their historical averages, performance over the ensuing several years has tended to range from higher than average to stupendous.
So, in theory, the keys to successful investing are simple:
- Have low exposure to securities or asset classes whose valuations are well above their historical averages.
- Have high exposure to securities or asset classes whose valuations are well below their historical averages.
- Have average exposure to securities or asset classes whose valuations are neither well above nor well below their historical averages.
If only Life were so Simple
Before you thank me for handing you the golden key to achieving better than average returns with relatively low risk, you should know that this approach comes with baggage that can make it difficult if not impossible for many to follow.
Although valuations have proven to be a very good predictor of longer-term, average returns, the same cannot be said over the short to medium term, for the simple reason that they tend to overshoot. One should never underestimate the ability of ridiculously valued assets to become even more so. Continue Reading…






