Tag Archives: RRSPs

Retired Money: When do Pension Buybacks of extra service make sense?

Posted By |
MoneySense: Photo by LinkedIn Sales Navigator on Unsplash

My latest MoneySense Retired Money column looks at the complex question of Pension Buybacks: putting extra money into a Defined Benefit pension to in effect “buy back” extra years of service. You can find the full column by clicking on the highlighted headline: Should you buy back pensions from your Employer? It ran on June 19th.

While this column often adds my own personal experience, this is a topic that I have never had the opportunity to explore. I can say that while I am now receiving pension income from two rather modest employer DB pension plans, the chance to buy back service never arose. If it had I probably would have jumped to take advantage of it as the guraranteed-for-life annuity-like nature of a DB plan strikes me as being particularly valuable, especially in these days of ultra-low interest rates and ever-more-volatile stock markets.

If your DB pension is inflation-indexed all the better. Again I lack such an employer pension and my wife is not in any pension at all, so our only experience in inflation-indexed pensions are the Government-issue CPP and OAS, so far deferred by my partner.

You will need cash for a buyback, or you can tap RRSPs or both. If cash, you must have available RRSP contribution room this year. Buybacks fall under the Past Service Pension Adjustment calculation, or PSPA. The PSPA reduces your RRSP in the current year, and Ottawa permits an $8,000 contribution beyond your RRSP room. Thus, the value of your buyback may be greater than your RRSP room once you consider employer contributions and future benefits.

In the MoneySense column, financial planner Matthew Ardrey of Tridelta Financial says the biggest “pro” for a buyback is simply a bigger pension at retirement. Since pensions reward longer service, buybacks let you buy more past service, and the deal is sweeter still if your employer matches contributions.

Longevity, interest rates, employer matching all considerations

Longevity can be a pro or a con, depending on when you die. The longer you live the more attractive the pension becomes, and with it the value of a buyback.   Continue Reading…

Taxes and your ETFs: Don’t let withholding taxes drive the bus

Posted By |

 

By Dale Roberts, CuttheCrapInvesting

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Should you pay attention to withholding taxes on dividends? What about about capital gains vs dividend income? Should tax considerations trump asset allocation and your risk tolerance level? I get many questions with respect to taxes and ETFs. I will suggest that you do not let taxation and withholding taxes on US and International dividends drive the bus.

Keep in mind that I am not a tax expert. When in doubt have a chat with your accountant or Certified Financial Planner. I form my opinion based on the study of asset allocation models. And I’ll also largely base the opinion after reading what the qualified experts have to say. I also make it a hobby to pester several portfolio managers and investment firms on a regular basis.

Should we worry about what goes where?

Taxes and ETFs and that TFSA question. A reader and friend recently asked if he should build the TFSA in the most tax-efficient manner? After all, in a TFSA we lose the withholding taxes on US and International dividends. There is often more dividend tax efficiency in taxable accounts thanks to tax credits. The most efficient account type for US stocks and US ETFs in a US dollar RRSP account.

Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

Does that mean we should only hold our US equities in our RRSP account?

Justin Bender of the Canadian Portfolio Manager blog constructed a wonderful post on the most tax efficient ETF Portfolio. Here’s how that tax efficient portfolio looked in the end.

Of course this is ridiculous as Justin would point out. Perhaps even shading the portfolio to any great degree does not make sense as well.

Don’t let taxation drive the asset allocation bus

In the above example the tax considerations determine the asset allocation. That in turn will determine the risk level and the ‘expected’ returns for each account type. You might get tax efficiency but no total returns in your taxable account. US stocks might tank and you get negative returns for an extended period in your RRSP account. That TFSA account has a Canadian home bias that so many advisors and financial planners would deplore. We still need those Canadian and US and International equities to ‘protect’ each other.

Of course the above portfolio example does not take into account the more important retirement funding scheme. aka the financial plan. We may need the TFSA account to work just as hard as the RRSP account. On the flip side, the financial plan may call for a quicker draw down of RRSP assets so that the retiree can delay CPP and OAS. That would require an RRSP portfolio at a lower risk level. Those are greater considerations.

It’s tax free after paying withholding taxes

And after tax returns in ETFs can get tricky. Here’s a great article in Advisor’s Edge. Continue Reading…

I’ve maxed out my TFSA and RRSP. Now what?

Posted By |

By Mark Seed

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Seriously, what a great problem to have!

Some readers have maxed out their TFSA and RRSP. Now what?

Here are some recent reader questions and comments (adapted for site):

Reader 1:

“I’ve finally been able to max out my TFSA and RRSP. I’m 41. Now what? Should I consider investing in a taxable account? If so, what should I own?”

Reader 2:

“Mark, I’ve been reading your site for years. I’ve put a priority on paying down our mortgage for many years now, and striving to max out our kids’ Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) every year for their financial future. Those have been priorities number one and two for years.

When the TFSA came along, I thought it would be an excellent place to keep our family emergency fund for our house repairs and small renovations in a tax-free way but I’ve since realized by reading your site that I should have thought of this as an investment account (like you did) since day 1. I now invest in low-cost ETFs inside this account and I’ve never looked back!  I have a six-figure portfolio thanks to you!

Now, with the mortgage balance down the high-five figures; RESPs maxed for our two kids and now our TFSAs maxed out as well – I’m thinking we should work on maxing out the RRSPs like you have and eventually get into taxable investing if we can.

Thoughts on my approach?”

Reader 3:

“Mark, I have been an avid reader of your blog for the last two years but this is my first intervention 🙂 Better later than never! My question today is how I can diversify my portfolio even more?

I’ve maxed out my registered accounts (RRSP: $32,000 in VEQT and TFSA: $75,000 also in VEQT) and invested significant chunks of money in a non-registered account ($50,000 in VEQT). I’m also helping my cousin with his RESP. I’ve also got an emergency fund with Tangerine.

At only 29, and single, I think I am off to a good start but it would be nice to find more ways to diversify my investments. I still have another $10,000 that I want to invest. What are some options?

  • Real estate? (not sure about this)  Maybe Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)?
  • Crowdfunding?
  • Peer-to-peer lending? (seems risky)
  • Other?

Looking forward to your thoughts Mark!”

Wow, great stuff readers.

I mean, people thinking about investing inside your taxable accounts after your registered accounts are maxed; readers paying down their mortgage while diligently investing; folks wondering how to invest in a taxable account now that their emergency fund, TFSA and RRSP are managed and full: amazing stuff!

Get invested and stay invested!

Now, what should these readers do???

Continue Reading…

Make that last-minute RRSP contribution a conservative one

Posted By |

By John De Goey, CFP, CIM

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Every year around this time, people like me pound their fists on the proverbial table for ordinary Canadians to make an RRSP contribution.  Spoiler alert: that’s what’s going to happen here, too.

What’s different in this post is that I’m going to go a little bit further than others in making my plea … but only a little bit.  I’m not going to recommend a specific security or product. I am, however, going to recommend a specific asset class: income.

So many people tell me that the reason they don’t contribute is that they don’t know what to invest in.  I gently point out to them that deciding about how to invest your little tax-deduction generator is not a pre-condition of contributing.  Just put the money into your RRSP based on the room available on your most recent notice of Assessment before Monday March 2, already.  Generate a refund …. or at least a reduction in the amount owing.

Many people make RRSP contributions in the second half of February and contribute nothing else throughout the remainder of the year.  For them, this is an annual tradition where they make a one-time contribution into whatever catches their fancy and pay precious little attention for the next 52 weeks or so.

Most people should be investing in Bonds this year

If this sounds like you … and if you already have a somewhat balanced portfolio that has some combination of stocks and bonds in it, then I suspect that the stock portion of your portfolio did very well in 2019 and the bond portion did relatively less well.   That simple reality is why most people should be investing in bonds this year.

Let’s say you’re a traditional balanced investor with a target of 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds.  If you started out a year ago with that asset allocation and your stocks were up 20% while your bonds were up 3% over the past year, then you could re-balance using the contribution. Continue Reading…

RRSPs are not a Scam: A Guide for the Anti-RRSP crowd

Posted By |

The anti-RRSP crowd must come from one of two schools of thought:

1.) They believe their tax rate will be higher in the withdrawal phase than in the contribution phase, or;

2.) They forgot about the deduction they received when they made the contribution in the first place.

No other options prior to TFSA

RRSPs are misunderstood today for several reasons. For one thing, older investors had no other options prior to the TFSA, so they might have contributed to their RRSP in their lower-income earning years without realizing this wasn’t the optimal approach.

Related: The beginner’s guide to RRSPs

RRSPs are meant to work as a tax-deferral strategy, meaning you get a tax-deduction on your contributions today and your investments grow tax-free until it’s time to withdraw the funds in retirement, a time when hopefully you’ll be taxed at a lower rate. So contributing to your RRSP makes more sense during your high-income working years rather than when you’re just starting out in an entry-level position.

Taxing withdrawals

A second reason why RRSPs are misunderstood is because of the concept of taxing withdrawals. The TFSA is easy to understand. Contribute $6,000 today, let your investment grow tax-free, and withdraw the money tax-free whenever you so choose.

With RRSPs you have to consider what is going to benefit you most from a tax perspective. Are you in your highest income earning years today? Will you be in a lower tax bracket in retirement? The same? Higher?

The RRSP and TFSA work out to be the same if you’re in the same tax bracket when you withdraw from your RRSP as you were when you made the contributions. An important caveat is that you have to invest the tax refund for RRSPs to work out as designed.

Future federal tax rates

Another reason why investors might think RRSPs are a bum deal? They believe federal tax rates are higher today, or will be higher in the future when it’s time to withdraw from their RRSP.

Is this true? Not so far. I checked historical federal tax rates from 1998-2000 and compared them to the tax rates for 2018 and 2019.

Federal tax rates 2018-2019 federal-tax-rate-1998-2000

The charts show that tax rates have actually decreased significantly for the middle class over the last two decades.

Someone who made $40,000 in 1998 would have paid $6,639 in federal taxes, or 16.6 per cent. After adjusting the income for inflation, someone who earned $59,759 in 2019 would pay $7,820 in federal taxes, or just 13.1 per cent.

Minimum RRIF withdrawals

It became clear over the last decade that the minimum RRIF withdrawal rules needed an overhaul. No one liked being forced to withdraw a certain percentage of their nest egg every year, especially when that percentage didn’t jive with today’s lower return environment and longer lifespans. Continue Reading…