Longevity & Aging

No doubt about it: at some point we’re neither semi-retired, findependent or fully retired. We’re out there in a retirement community or retirement home, and maybe for a few years near the end of this incarnation, some time to reflect on it all in a nursing home. Our Longevity & Aging category features our own unique blog posts, as well as blog feeds from Mark Venning’s ChangeRangers.com and other experts.

A new take on death and cross-border taxes

Posted By |

By Elena Hanson

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Many Canadians work in the United States. But what if you worked there, owned an IRA (Individual Retirement Account), came back, and died here? What happens to the beneficiaries?

It depends on your age, marital status, and who the beneficiaries are. Add to that maturity of the account itself and what type of IRA it is. Furthermore, on December 20, 2019, President Donald Trump signed into law the ‘Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act’ (SECURE Act), which changed some key IRA rules. This kind of scenario can easily wind up as a dog’s breakfast, especially in the hands of a lawyer, accountant or financial advisor who isn’t up to snuff on the ins and outs of an IRA.

In a traditional IRA contributions are tax-deferred, as they are with a Canadian RRSP, and income is taxed in the U.S. when the money is paid out. U.S. law is such that account owners must begin to make required minimum withdrawals when they turn 72. This is like a RRIF in Canada. But if you pass away before that withdrawal period begins, there are three options for reporting the interest, as per one’s Canadian tax responsibilities:

1.) Include the fair market value of the IRA which becomes taxable on the Canadian income tax return of the deceased for the year of death.

2.) Include the fair market value of the IRA on a separate ‘Rights or Things’ income tax return which is due one year after the date of death.

3.) Legally transfer the rights to the account to a beneficiary, but this must be done within a certain period. Such an option is available only to beneficiaries designated in the IRA. If that beneficiary is Canadian, they must include the interest on their Canadian tax return. If the beneficiary is not Canadian, the amount is not taxed here.

What if you die after withdrawal begins?

Now, what if you pass away after the withdrawal period begins? This is a whole new kettle of fish because you, or your beneficiary, are dealing directly with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

Let’s say the deceased person passed away in 2020 but began making withdrawals in 2015. In that situation their interest in the IRA is not regarded as ‘Rights or Things.’ The amount of any annuity payment is included in the income of the deceased for the year of death: in this case, 2018. The balance would then be reported by the beneficiaries on their income tax return when they receive the payments after inheriting the account, and this would continue for as long as they are designated as direct beneficiaries.

This is where it’s important to have a tax professional – your lawyer, accountant or financial advisor – knowledgeable about IRAs. In fact, the U.S. levies income taxes only when amounts are paid out from an IRA.

So, assume a Canadian person who owns an IRA suddenly dies before their withdrawal period commences, and their designated beneficiary is also Canadian.

In this scenario the third option may be best; legally transfer the rights to the account to a beneficiary, and when that person receives payments, they must pay a 15% U.S. tax withholding. In addition, they must report the payment on their Canadian tax return but can claim the 15% U.S. tax withholding as a foreign tax credit.

However, if your advisor isn’t familiar with how an IRA works or IRS rules, the result may be the dog’s breakfast referred to earlier. For example, with Option #1 or #2, Canada ends up double-dipping on the IRA. Canada taxes the full value of the IRA in the year of death.

IRAs aren’t taxed until distributed in the U.S.

However, in the U.S., the IRA does not get taxed until it has been distributed. So, what ends up happening is that in the year of death, Canada gets its first dip by taxing the IRA on the decedent’s tax return. Later on, when the IRA gets distributed, the U.S. will tax the same income once it is distributed to the Canadian beneficiary, and Canada dips again by taxing the same income on the beneficiary’s tax return this time around.

Therefore, option #3 is best because it prevents the IRA from being taxed in full twice. Paying tax on your interest once is enough. Who wants to pay it twice? But this can, and does, happen. Continue Reading…

How to enjoy your Retirement years on a Fixed Income

Posted By |
Photo via Rawpixel

By Sharon Wagner

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

For many new retirees, adapting to a fixed income can be a bit of a challenge. However, living on a limited budget shouldn’t take any fulfillment out of your golden years. With a few budget tweaks and some smart financial planning, you’ll be able to enjoy today and remain financially secure for the future. Here are some quick budgeting tips for financial success now that you’re retired.

Cut unnecessary subscriptions and services

If you’re not careful, memberships and subscriptions can eat up a lot of your budget. For example, canceling your cable subscription and replacing it with an inexpensive streaming service can save you hundreds of dollars a year! Gone are the days of paying for a bunch of channels you never watch. If you decide to cut the cord and do away with your cable box, you’ll want to get a streaming device so you can watch your favorite shows and movies on your TV. Simply compare streaming devices to match the features and the right device with your budget.

Spend less on food

Eating out frequently can eat a massive hole in your budget. According to Nestle Professional, senior households spend thousands on eating out every year! Considering that cooking a meal at home costs a fraction of dining out, you can save a significant amount of money by spending more time in the kitchen.

Get familiar with some quick and easy meals that you can throw together the next time you’re tempted to order takeout. You can also take steps to cut down on grocery spending: review flyers and look for deals, write a shopping list, and don’t buy anything that’s not on your list.

Pay off debt

If you have debt, make a plan to pay it off as soon as possible. Any money you pay in interest on your debt is money you can’t spend on fun retirement hobbies and activities. Kiplinger recommends starting by focusing on high-interest debt. Credit card debt can be particularly burdensome, so do whatever you can to avoid taking on more. Medical debt can also be overwhelming, but credit experts advise against prioritizing this type of debt since it typically carries low to no zero interest. Continue Reading…

Celebrating Findependence Man. Five Years On!

Posted By |
By Mark Venning, ChangeRangers.com

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

In between meetings with your financial planning advisor, where do you go for ongoing news and commentary on personal financial matters? If you live in North America there is a wealth, so to speak, of media options, books and seminars to pick from, but one reliable source for news and views that has served up some of the best, curated content over the last five years is the website Findependence Hub, produced by Jonathan Chevreau.

Author of the book Findependence Day, Chevreau got the idea for this title around 2008, just before the financial crisis. As Jonathan tells me, “It just came to me one day, when I was playing around with the idea of Financial Independence and the American Independence Day … Financial Independence was a bit of a mouthful, so shortened it to Findependence.”

Isn’t that the way most of today’s catchy brand names or tag lines come to life?

Uniquely, the Findependence Day book has a Canadian and US version. Jonathan describes it as, “a Wealthy Barber-ish financial fiction format,” based on a story of a couple undergoing their financial life cycle as they experience the usual modern churn in a narrative of job loss, buying a home, raising children, investing and pensions, starting a business all the while navigating stock market volatility and other life dilemmas.

True, Jonathan says, “David Chilton’s classic bestseller Wealthy Barber spawned many imitators but I tried to be a bit different with my book … it makes an attempt to incorporate real elements of traditional fiction: plot, characterization, setting, including frequent “setbacks” or conflicts between the characters that keep people reading. It turns out that the ‘setback’ or conflict structure of fiction is well suited to portraying financial planning.” Continue Reading…

Retired Money: David Aston’s The SleepEasy Retirement Guide

Posted By |

My latest MoneySense Retired Money column is one of the first review of financial writer David Aston’s first book, The SleepEasy Retirement Guide. The subtitle bills the book as answering “the 12 biggest financial questions that keep you up at night.” Click on the highlighted text to retrieve the full column: Good News — Your RRSP is probably in better shape than you think.

Aston is a long-time freelance financial writer, and is also a MoneySense writer. I got to know him when I was the editor and always enjoyed editing his popular Retirement column in the magazine. Now 63, after a corporate career spanning management consulting, corporate financial planning, and operations, Aston turned to financial journalism, which he has now been doing for 12 years.

As I note in the review, I had a small role to play in the creation of this book, since I introduced David to the publisher: Milner & Associates Inc., which is also the publisher of Victory Lap Retirement, coauthored by myself and Mike Drak.

In the case of Aston’s new book, I have to say it seems to have been a good piece of literary matchmaking. In due course, we hope to run some excerpts and/or blogs from David here on the Hub.

A nice feature of the book are the many charts and tables that spell out just how much money you need to accumulate to retire at various ages, whether a “barebones” el cheapo lifestyle, or a high-end luxury one defined as $100,000 in annual income for couples ($80,000 for singles) or the vast swath of retired lifestyles in between. Whether you’re single or half of a couple, all the numbers you need to project finances into your future golden years are there. For most of the calculations in these charts, Aston created simple Excel spreadsheets.

No need for $1 million unless you want a deluxe Retirement

Financial writer and author David Aston

And, as is often made clear at MoneySense.ca, you don’t necessarily need $1 million to retire, although you will need that much and more if you are counting on a deluxe retirement with all the bells and whistles (exotic travel once or twice a year, two cars in the garage, eating out regularly, etc.). Continue Reading…

Retired Money: Can an RRSP or a RRIF ever be “too large?”

Posted By |
MoneySense.ca

My latest MoneySense Retired Money column looks at a problem some think is a nice one for retirees to have: can an RRSP — and ultimately a RRIF — ever become too large? You can find the full column by clicking on the adjacent highlighted headline: How large an RRSP is too large for Retirement?

This is a surprisingly controversial topic. Some financial advisors advocate “melting down” RRSPs in the interim period between full employment and the end of one’s 71st year, when RRIFs are typically slated to begin their annual (and taxable) minimum withdrawals. Usually, RRSP meltdowns occur in your 60s: I began to do so personally a few years ago, albeit within the confines of a very conservative approach to the 4% Rule.

As the piece points out, tax does start to become problematic upon the death of the first member of a senior couple. At that point, a couple no longer has the advantage of having two sets of income streams taxed in two sets of hands: ideally in lower tax brackets.

True, the death of the first spouse may not be a huge tax problem, since the proceeds of RRSPs and RRIFs pass tax-free to the survivor, assuming proper beneficiary designations. But that does result in a far larger RRIF in the hands of the survivor, which means much of the rising annual taxable RRIF withdrawals may start to occur in the higher tax brackets. And of course if both members of a couple die with a huge combined RRIF, their heirs may share half the estate with the Canada Revenue Agency.

For many seniors, the main reason to start drawing down early on an RRSP is to avoid or minimize clawbacks of Old Age Security (OAS) benefits, which begin for most at age 65. One guideline is any RRSP or RRIF that exceeds the $77,580 (in 2019) threshold where OAS benefits begin to get clawed back. Of course you also need to consider your other income sources, including employer pensions, CPP and non-registered income.

Adrian Mastracci

“A nice problem to have.”

But the MoneySense column also introduces the counterargument nicely articulated by Adrian Mastracci, fiduciary portfolio manager with Vancouver-based Lycos Asset Management. Mastracci, who is also a blogger and occasional contributor to the Hub, is fond of saying to clients “A too-large RRSP is a nice problem to have!”

Retirement can last a long time: from 65 to the mid 90s can be three decades: a long time for portfolios to keep delivering. A larger RRIF down the road gives retirees more financial options, given the ravages of inflation, rising life expectancies, possible losses in bear markets, low-return environments and rising healthcare costs in one’s twilight years. These factors are beyond investors’ control, in which case Mastracci quips, “So much for the too-big RRSP.”