Tag Archives: RRSP

FP: RRSPs still have at least 3 advantages over TFSAs

Posted By |

My latest Financial Post column has just been published. It being the height of RRSP season, it looks at some well-known and some less well-known advantages RRSPs still have over the new kid on the block: TFSAs. Click on the highlighted text for the full story online: Three reasons why RRSPs still matter — and one of them you probably didn’t know. The article is also in Wednesday’s print edition on page FP6 under the headline RRSPs still matter despite rise of TFSAs.

The Tax-free Savings Account (TFSA), which was introduced just over ten years ago, is often described as the “mirror imaqe” of the RRSP. That is, the RRSP provides an upfront tax deduction by lowering your taxable income for the year you make the contribution. The TFSA does not, which can be a strike against it in some eyes; on the other hand, once you reach retirement, the TFSA comes into its own by NOT being taxable, and therefore not resulting in clawbacks of Old Age Security (OAS) benefits or (for very low-income seniors) the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) to the OAS.

On the other hand, as many seniors are discovering to their chagrin, all those RRSP tax savings you enjoyed during your (hopefully) high-income earning years come back to haunt you: once the RRSP becomes a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) at the end of the year you turn 71 (the alternative is the unpalatable act of cashing it all out and being taxed then and there, or annuitizing), then you’ll be on the hook for forced annual — and taxable — RRIF withdrawals. Ottawa giveth and Ottawa taketh away.

But, as the FP piece argues, some decades can elapse between an RRSP contribution and the ultimate RRIF withdrawals, and when you add in the ongoing tax sheltering of an RRSP — on top of the upfront tax contribution — then the experts quoted in the piece believe the RRSP comes out, certainly if you’re at or near the top tax brackets.

Below is the arithmetic provided by Mathew Ardrey, wealth adviser at TriDelta Financial, which was too long to include in the FP version. He cites the example of someone who has $10,000 of income and can invest in either a TFSA or a RRSP:

 

Same tax rate
RRSP TFSA
Income before taxes to save $10,000 $10,000
Tax at 50% $0 ($5,000)
After-tax available to contribute $10,000 $5,000
FV with 5% return for 25 years $33,864 $16,932
Tax at 50% ($16,932) $0
After-tax withdrawal in retirement $16,932 $16,932
Lower tax rate in retirement
RRSP TFSA
Income before taxes to save $10,000 $10,000
Tax at 50% $0 ($5,000)
After-tax available to contribute $10,000 $5,000
FV with 5% return for 25 years $33,864 $16,932
Tax at 25% ($8,466) $0
After-tax withdrawal in retirement $25,398 $16,932
Higher tax rate in retirement
RRSP TFSA
Income before taxes to save $10,000 $10,000
Tax at 25% $0 ($2,500)
After-tax available to contribute $10,000 $7,500
FV with 5% return for 25 years $33,864 $25,398
Tax at 50% ($16,932) $0
After-tax withdrawal in retirement $16,932 $25,398

 

Tridelta Financial’s Matthew Ardrey

“The part of the example I would focus on, is what is a reality for many Canadians, their income is higher while they are working than in retirement. Because of this, there is a clear advantage of receiving the deduction at a higher marginal tax rate and paying tax in retirement at a lower marginal tax rate,” Ardrey concludes.

Foreign income taxed less harshly in RRSPs than TFSAs

But that’s not all! As the FP column mentions, there are at least two other advantages RRSPs have over TFSAs. One is that foreign income is taxed more in TFSAs than in RRSPs: Continue Reading…

Thinking about retirement? Here are 2 two key income sources to expect

Posted By |

By Scott Ronalds

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

If you’re at the point where you’re starting to think seriously about retirement, you’re probably wondering how much money you’re going to need to enjoy life after work, and where it’s going to come from.

Everybody’s wants and needs are different, so there’s no magic number as to how much you should have saved by a certain age. Plus, the face of retirement has changed significantly, with many people working part-time into their seventies and eighties, and others hanging it up in their fifties.

That said, by making a few assumptions, we can give you a rough estimate of what you can expect from government sources and your portfolio when you decide to retire.

The basics

To keep it simple, we’ll use a scenario which assumes you’re 65 and plan to fully retire from your job this year. A few other assumptions:

  • You don’t have a pension plan with your employer.
  • You’re eligible for full Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS) benefits.
  • You have an RSP that you plan to convert to a RIF this year, and you plan to take the minimum required payments (which will start next year) from your account. (Note: you aren’t required to convert your RSP to a RIF until the calendar year you turn 71, but you can convert at any age before 71 if you choose).
  • You don’t have any other investments or sources of income.

First off, let’s look at what you’ll get from the government. You can expect monthly CPP payments of roughly $1,114 ($13,370/year) and OAS payments of about $578 ($6,936/year). In total, you can plan on collecting about $1,690 a month, or just over $20,000 a year. These amounts are indexed to inflation. You can decide to defer taking CPP benefits until you’re older, or take them earlier, in which case your benefits will be increased or decreased, respectively. You can also defer taking OAS to receive a larger monthly benefit.

More than likely, this isn’t going to cover your living expenses or fund the lifestyle you want in retirement. So you’re going to need to rely on your portfolio to cover the shortfall.

RIFing it

Converting your RSP to a RIF means your minimum withdrawal next year will be equivalent to 4.0% of your portfolio’s year-end market value. This figure is based on your age, 65, at the end of the current calendar year. Continue Reading…

How to Retire debt-free

Posted By |

By Laurie Campbell

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

These days, don’t be surprised to find a senior citizen standing behind the counter of your favourite fast food spot taking your order instead of a braces-wearing teen. What retirement looks like today has changed quite significantly from what it was even just ten years ago, and there’s no stopping this trend. More and more seniors are staying in the workforce, and for many of them, they have no choice.

Last June for Seniors Month, our agency, Credit Canada co-sponsored a seniors and money study that looked at the financial difficulties Canadian seniors are facing; the results, while shocking, were no surprise.

As a non-profit credit counselling agency, our counsellors are on the forefront of what’s happening when it comes to people and their financial hardships, and we are seeing a large number of people who should be starting to settle into their “golden years” still working, maybe even taking on an additional side job, just to pay off their debt, let alone get a time-share in Florida.

When we conducted our study in June 2018, it revealed that one-in-five Canadians are still working past age 60, including six per cent of those 80 and older. And while one third do so simply because they want to — which is fantastic, kudos to you — 60 per cent are still working because of some form of financial hardship, whether it’s too much debt, not enough savings, or other financial responsibilities, like supporting adult children.

The truth is the golden years have been tarnished, and I don’t know if we’ll ever get them back.

Half of 60-plus carrying some form of debt

Many of today’s retirees are living on fixed incomes, making them vulnerable to unpaid debt. In fact, our study revealed more than half of Canadians age 60 and older are carrying at least one form of debt, with a quarter carrying two or more types of debt. What’s even more alarming is that 35 per cent of seniors age 80 and older have debt, including credit-card debt and even car loans.

Staring at the problem isn’t going to help, nor is hiding from it. The best thing we can all do is to face the facts head-on and devise a plan of action that we know will work, whether it’s getting rid of any debt while building up savings, taking on a side job, delaying retirement by a few years, or all of the above.

Sizing up Government support

Before delving into the numbers it’s important to understand what income you can expect to have during your retirement. A few numbers have been compiled here as an example, but if you wanted to get more detailed information you can visit the Government of Canada website and click on the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) or Old Age Security (OAS) pages.

So, let’s get started by taking a look at 2017. Continue Reading…

Top retirement advisor tips to get the most from your savings

Posted By |

All investments come with a mix of risk and potential reward. The greatest danger comes when you understand the mechanics of an investment, but you’re missing some of the details. Your understanding of the potential reward can make you greedy, while the gaps in your knowledge limit your natural, healthy sense of skepticism.

When it comes to retirement, you should be long-term focused, which takes a lot of the guessing and game playing out of the equation. The best retirement plan you can have is to start saving as early in your working career as possible. You then invest a steady or rising amount of that money in the stock market every year. When you follow this plan, you automatically profit from dollar-cost averaging. You will automatically buy more shares when prices are low, and fewer shares when prices are high.

Continue reading for more retirement advisor tips and strategies for saving.

Retirement advisor tip: Use an RRSP For Retirement

You have to learn a lot of things to become a successful investor, and few people learn them all in any logical progression. Instead, most of us move from one subject of interest to another, with a lot of zigs and zags in between.

But one tip is clear: If you want to pay less tax on your investments while you’re still working, investing in an RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan) is the way to go.

To cut tax bills, RRSPs are a great option. RRSPs are a form of tax-deferred savings plan. RRSP contributions are tax deductible, and the investments grow tax-free. (Note that you can currently contribute up to 18% of your earned income from the previous year. March 1 is the last day you can contribute to an RRSP and deduct your contribution from your previous year’s income.) When you later begin withdrawing the funds from your RRSP, they are taxed as ordinary income.

Registered Retirement Income Funds (RRIFs) are also a great long-term retirement investment planning strategy

Converting your RRSP to a RRIF is clearly one of the best of three alternatives at age 71. That’s because RRIFs offer more flexibility and tax savings than annuities or a lump-sum withdrawal (which in most cases is a poor retirement investing option, since you’ll be taxed on the entire amount in that year as ordinary income).

Like an RRSP, a RRIF can hold a range of investments. You don’t need to sell your RRSP holdings when you convert—you just transfer them to your RRIF. Continue Reading…

Retired Money: How to boost Retirement Income with Fred Vettese’s 5 enhancements

Posted By |

 Once they move from the wealth accumulation phase to “decumulation” retirees and near-retirees start to focus on how to boost Retirement Income.

The latest instalment of my MoneySense Retired Money column looks at five “enhancements” to do this, all contained in Fred Vettese’s about-to-be-published book, Retirement Income for Life, subtitled Getting More Without Saving More. You can find the full column by clicking on this highlighted headline: A Guide to Having Retirement Income for Life.

You’ll be seeing various reviews of this book as it becomes available online late in February and likely in bookstores by early March. I predict it will be a bestseller since it taps the huge market of baby boomers turning 65 (1,100 every day!): including author Fred Vettese and even Yours Truly in a few months time.

That’s because a lot of people need help in generating a pension-like income from savings, typically RRSPs, group RRSPs and Defined Contribution plans, TFSAs, non-registered investments and the like. In other words, anybody who doesn’t enjoy a guaranteed-for-life Defined Benefit pension plan, of the type that are still common in the public sector but becoming rare in the private sector.

The core of the book are the five “enhancements” Vettese has identified that help to ensure that those seeking to pensionize their nest eggs (to paraphrase the title of Moshe Milevsky’s book that covers some of this ground) don’t outlive their money. Vettese says many of these concepts are current in the academic literature but have been slow to migrate to the mainstream, in part because few of these “enhancements” will be welcomed by the typical commission-compensated financial advisor. That in itself will make this book controversial.

Each of these “enhancements” get a whole chapter but in a nutshell they are:

1.) Enhancement 1: Reducing Fees

By moving from high-fee mutual funds or similar vehicles to low-cost ETFs (exchange-traded funds), Vettese explains how investment fees can be cut from 1.5 to 3% to as little as 0.5% a year, all of which goes directly to boosting retirement income flows. One of his takeaways is that “Tangible evidence of added value from active management is hard to find.”

2.)  Enhancement 2: Deferring CPP Pension

We’ve covered the topic of deferring CPP to age 70 frequently in various articles, some of which can be found here on the Hub’s search engine. Even so, very few Canadians opt to wait till age 70 to collect the Canada Pension Plan. Because CPP is a valuable inflation-indexed guaranteed for life instrument — in effect, an annuity that you can never outlive — Vettese argues for deferral, although he (like me) is fine with taking Old Age Security as soon as it’s available at age 65. He argues that for someone who contributed to CPP until age 65, they can boost their CPP income by almost 50% by waiting till 70 to collect.  “You are essentially transferring some of your investment risk and longevity risk back to the government, and you are doing so at zero cost.” Continue Reading…