Reviews

We review books that deal with everything from financial independence topics to politics, and anything in between. We may sometimes stray into films and music if there is a “Findependence” angle.

Millennials want to FIRE at age 50

Posted By |

By Mark Seed, MyOwnAdvisor

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Whether you agree with the FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) movement or not – it’s a big thing.

Personally, I’m a huge believer in clear goals. If FIRE at age 50 is your goal, go for it.

Goals can be positive, purposeful and motivating. I think goals are great because they force you into choices.

Pursuing financial Independence is a choice.

That said, I’ve learned to let go a bit. Spend a bit. Relax a bit. Enjoy things just a bit more. 

In case you missed it, some people can work too hard, too long and save too much for retirement.

Make FI a goal but not life’s final destination

I make financial goals like these every year to help me/us stay focused on our choices.

Whether you are in your 20s, 30s, 40s or 50s aspiring for some form of earlier retirement than most – if that’s your choice – just consider what you’ll do with your time when you get there. FI is a great goal, just don’t make it a final destination.

Millennial FIRE at age 50 case study

I’ve been fortunate to receive emails from dozens, if not hundreds of readers in recent years asking me what it takes to build a 7-figure portfolio, can I retire with X amount of money, and what would a world of living off dividends and distributions could be like.

Well, I will tell you my goal to live off dividends and distributions remains alive and well!

I will continue to answer those questions from readers as much as possible – so keep them coming.

But given those questions, I figured I’d share yet another case study for a reader/lurker on my site.

Before we get to that new case study, a reminder you can check out these previous posts about folks striving to retire or semi-retire earlier than most AND what that takes:

Here is one proven path to retirement ignoring any 4% rule.

Karla and Toby are 54 and 56. Can they retire soon with $1.2 million in the bank and no company pensions?

Mike and Julie want to spend $50,000 per year in retirement starting in their 50s…how much do they need?

This 50-something couple wants to FIRE at 52. How much can they spend?

Millennials want to FIRE at age 50 – can they do it?

A reader of the site emailed me to discuss their early retirement dreams. Let’s look at their case study and find out what it takes to FIRE at age 50.

Here is their profile and what they told me:

  • Judy (F), and Shane (M), aged 35.
  • Judy is currently pregnant, and they are expecting their first child later this year.
  • They live in Kingston, ON.
  • They both work full-time for now.

“Mark, can we FIRE at 50?” If so, “what will our assets look like at age 50 assuming we try and max out contributions to our TFSAs at minimum every single year?”

To help answer these questions, I once again enlisted some help. Welcome back Owen Winkelmolen (no affiliation) who is a fee-for-service financial planner (QAFP) and founder of PlanEasy.ca. Owen specializes in budgeting, cashflow, taxes & benefits, and retirement planning – working with both individuals and young families to help them with comprehensive financial plans from today to age 100.

Owen, thoughts for Judy and Shane?

Thanks Mark and glad to be back on your site. I love these case studies!

First, before we share the results, let’s provide some inputs and background data for context. Based on their information to you, we’ve included this information below in their projections with some assumptions as well:

  • Judy works full-time, for now, making a solid $95,000 per year as engineer with performance bonus opportunities at work of up to 15% (although the latter is never expected).
  • Shane is an HVAC mechanic making up to $80,000 per year.
  • They have a sizeable mortgage: $350,000. They hope to have it paid off in 10 years and as of now, with a child on the way, they have no plans to move.
  • For the most part, they’ve been quite smart – owning both cars/vehicles. They plan to replace Shane’s truck in another 5-7 years so they have established a “car fund”. They have $15,000 saved up already!
  • They’ve read your site Mark (about your emergency fund and have gone well beyond that with a child on the way) and keep about $25,000 in cash as an emergency fund. 

Mark to Owen: we did it – why we have an emergency fund.

  • They’ve worked hard and investing wisely. Mark told me they have about $100,000 invested inside each of their TFSAs – contributions are now maxed out since they’ve been contributing to their TFSAs since account inception.
  • RRSPs are not yet maxed out – there is only so much money to go around. Judy has an RRSP value of $110,000; Shane about $90,000.
  • They have also told Mark they intend to start contributing to a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) in the coming years for their child.
  • Neither Judy nor Shane have any workplace pension.

We’re going to make a few assumptions based on the information they also provided:

  • That their home has a value of $500,000 now and they will pay off the mortgage as planned as best they can.
  • Their interest rate is about 2.3%, with payments estimated to be about $2,200 per month.
  • They have no other debt – no credit cards, nothing.
  • We’re not sure if they plan to have other children so we won’t make any assumptions there!
  • We’ll also assume Judy sticks to her plan and stays at home for a bit but will return to work/work form home after about 6 months have passed. Shane also wants to be at home a bit. For daycare, they are lucky, they told Mark they have some help!

Owen: here is what the FIRE at 50 math says!

Judy and Shane have done an excellent job setting themselves up for financial independence and early retirement. Their plan is very robust and includes lots of flexibility. That flexibility will allow them to choose to spend more in the future and find a better balance between saving and spending or retire earlier than they planned. Continue Reading…

Book Review of Beyond Brochures: an insider’s guide to the Travel Business

Posted By |


By Ruth Snowden

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Hopefully by summer’s end, travel will start to return.

In this little gem of a Traveller’s guide readers will find dozens of precious nuggets, gleaned from the experience of a ‘well-seasoned’ Traveller, written with a light touch, a definite opinion and a good sprinkling of humour.

A bit skeptical at first, I wasn’t sure how anyone could write a book targeted to two different readers, the Traveller and the Travel Advisor, as announced in the introduction.  Within a few pages, though, it was evident that Picken honestly believes that although Travellers and Travel Advisors are on different sides of the same transaction, mutual understanding is a good thing and ‘the more people travel intelligently the better the world should be.’

He then proceeds to draw his readers into the joy of travelling, in 98 chapters: each a succinct one or two pages, divided into three distinct parts: Travellers, Travel Advisors, Travelling.  In every section are valuable hints and suggestions to help Travel Advisors make their customers’ experiences favourable and unforgettable, in a good way.

Building trust is not easy, especially in this world of virtual engagement and digital communication. In Beyond Brochures Picken provides readers with such solid insights that the Traveller reader naturally trusts him and Travel Advisors who follow his advice will be better able to create trust with their customers.

I am another seasoned traveller, having logged thousands of miles on business and leisure travel over many decades, much of which I’ve booked myself and some for which we needed a Travel Advisor.  For both the neophyte Traveller and for someone who has been there and done that, Section A is chock-a-block with important information: government websites; the regulatory environment and jurisdictions governing air travel; demystifying how airlines price seats; and agreeing that in many cases it is easy to book your own hotel room, without the assistance of a Travel Advisor.

Even when booking your own hotel rooms, the author shares great tips on how to use the ubiquitous on-line booking engines and suggests additional actions you can take to save money. Beyond Brochures will make me a better customer of a Travel Advisor and will make my self-directed and self-booked travel more enjoyable.

The philosophy behind why we travel

Early in this section he looks at what we look for in travel that is interesting and enjoyable to us: the philosophy behind why we travel. Continue Reading…

Wealthsimple Trade review: Canada’s only Zero-commission trading platform

Posted By |

Wealthsimple Trade is Canada’s first and only zero-commission trading platform. In this Wealthsimple Trade review I’ll explain how you can buy AND sell from among the thousands of stocks and ETFs listed on North American exchanges without paying any fees.

I first heard about Wealthsimple Trade in 2018 when it was announced as a new self-directed investing platform that lets investors buy and sell stocks and ETFs with no trading commissions. They invited users to join a wait list and, once they attained a critical mass (130,000 participants), rolled out a beta version for users to test the platform and offer feedback.

Wealthsimple Trade officially launched in March 2019 and at that time only supported non-registered trading accounts. Later that year, the platform added RRSP and TFSA account types to its lineup. That’s when I became interested in the platform for my own self-directed investing needs.

Get a $10 cash bonus and commission-free trades when you open a Wealthsimple Trade account and deposit and trade at least $100 worth of stock.

Why I switched to Wealthsimple Trade

I’ve held my investments at TD Direct Investing since 2009. It was out of convenience, more than anything, since I had banked with TD since I was a teenager. Back then trades disgustingly cost $29 per transaction. Today, they’re still a painful $9.99 per trade. I had enough when I noticed I paid a total of $190 in trading commissions with TD last year. No more.

I opened a Wealthsimple Trade account on January 13 2020, with the goal to bring my trading commissions down to zero. That same day, I initiated the transfer of my entire RRSP and TFSA account balances. Both of these accounts were invested in Vanguard’s all-equity balanced portfolio – VEQT – and so I requested an in-kind transfer which simply transferred the shares from TD to Wealthsimple Trade without first having to sell them.

An email from Wealthsimple suggested an expected wait time of up to five weeks to complete a transfer request with TD. But to my surprise I noticed the funds in my Wealthsimple Trade account on January 21 2020: just seven business days later.

Now that you have the back story, let’s take a look at the platform.

About Wealthsimple Trade

As mentioned, Wealthsimple Trade launched in March 2019 as Canada’s first and only zero-commission trading platform. It’s a separate, yet complementary service to Wealthsimple’s main business as Canada’s top robo advisor. With offices in Canada, the U.S., and the U.K., Wealthsimple manages more than $5 billion in assets worldwide.

Related: How to transfer your RRSP to Wealthsimple

Automated investing through a robo-advisor isn’t for everyone. Some investors want to take the reins themselves, build their own custom portfolio, and make trades in their own self-directed account. Enter Wealthsimple Trade.

While most online brokerages charge $9.99 per trade, Wealthsimple Trade doesn’t charge anything to buy and sell stocks or ETFs. It doesn’t charge account fees or have any account minimums to get started.

To get the costs down to the bare minimum (zero) the platform strips out all of the expensive bells and whistles. You won’t find cutting edge research or real-time quotes (there’s a 15-minute lag). Wealthsimple Trade also started out as a mobile app – on your smart-phone or tablet – with no desktop platform access. That, thankfully, has changed and Wealthsimple Trade now offers desktop access (January 2021):

But for self-directed investors who want to build a simple low-cost portfolio of index ETFs, and who want to contribute frequently without getting dinged each time they buy or sell, Wealthsimple Trade is the perfect platform.

Signing up and opening an account

How do you open an account? Easy. Download the Wealthsimple Trade app on your Apple or Android device and select ‘Get Started’. From there, follow the prompts to enter your information and agree to your account documents.

Note that even though the Wealthsimple Trade app is NOT connected at all to the Wealthsimple robo advisor platform: existing Wealthsimple clients can skip some of the preliminary questions.

Here’s what you’ll need to get started:

  • Full Name, Email, Mailing Address, Phone number, Date of Birth
  • Social Insurance Number
  • Employment information

There are no account minimums or fees associated with opening the account. To fund it, though, you’ll need to link a chequing or savings account.

Transferring investments to Wealthsimple Trade

Transferring my existing investments to Wealthsimple Trade couldn’t have been easier. As mentioned, I initiated the transfer on January 13, 2020. I entered a few details about the accounts I was transferring, selected the institution (TD) from a list of choices, and snapped a picture of my account statements.

WS Trade covers transfer fees

WS Trade Uploading your Account Statement

Next, I indicated how I wanted the transfer to take place. Typically, you can choose to transfer funds in cash, meaning your institution sells your current holdings and then moves the money. If you go this route, you may incur DSC or trading fees. Note that your contribution room or taxes won’t be affected when you transfer a non-taxable account like an RRSP or TFSA.

Instead, I chose to transfer my account in-kind or “as-is.” This means your institution transfers your entire account. Note that Wealthsimple Trade only accepts the transfer of stocks and ETFs. You’ll have the option to sell non-eligible assets like mutual funds, bonds, or options, or leave them with your institution.

As I said earlier, the entire transfer process took just seven business days. Your mileage may vary.

Using Wealthsimple Trade

Wealthsimple Trade works like any other online brokerage, with the exception that it’s a mobile-only platform. There’s no desktop support. Continue Reading…

Review: The Disciplined Trader

Posted By |

81o4jz+QTgLI am not and never will be a “trader,” in the sense of a full-time stock-picker/market-timer.

However, on the suggestion of my financial advisor, I recently ordered and read a copy of a classic trading book called The Disciplined Trader, by Mark Douglas (New York Institute of Finance, 1990).

Personally, my main interest in the topic involves hedging downside risk:  taking actions that limit some downside, at the expense of some potential upside. What surprised me about this book — which bears the subtitle Developing Winning Attitudes — is how much space was allocated to psychology and mental attitudes. In fact, fully all of the third of the four major sections is devoted to what I would call “softer” topics like understanding the nature of the mental environment, how memories, associations and beliefs manage environmental information, managing mental energy and similar topics. Continue Reading…

The ideal Stock

Posted By |

By Ian Duncan MacDonald

Special to the Financial Independence

The “good” dividends of financially strong companies provide a reliable income and increase the odds for an ever-rising share price.

There are 14,982 corporations in North America with common shares for purchase. For a strong, diversified portfolio you need only find 20 corporations whose shares come closest to matching the following “ideal criteria.”

(1) A stock price greater than $100
(2) A stock price that was greater than $100 four years ago
(3) A stock price that is now 99.50% greater than it was 4 years ago
(4) A stock with a book value greater than $100
(5) A current stock price greater than 49.5% of the book value
(6) Five or more analysts rating the stock a “buy”
(7) Five or more analysts rating the stock a “strong buy”
(8) A dividend yield percent between 7.50% and 10.49%.
(9) An operating margin greater than 79.50%
(10) An average daily volume of shares traded greater than 2,000,000
(11) A stock’s price-to-earnings ratio between 0.1x to 5.49x

In 20 years of reviewing thousands of stocks I have never found a stock that met all eleven criteria. Therefore, since the ideal stock does not exist it means you must sort through those 14,982 stocks to find those 20 that come closest to matching the 11 criteria.

To help identify the best dividend stocks, I score stocks using the above 11 criteria (my background was in commercial risk systems with Dun & Bradstreet, Equifax, etc). When the 11 scores are added they have the potential to reach a total of 100. After scoring thousands of stocks the highest score I have ever calculated is 78; the lowest score is 8. I avoid buying stocks scoring under 50.

Why dividends are important in Value investing

The best portfolio candidates emerge when you sort, by descending score, all 628 U.S. common stocks traded on the NYSE and the NASDAQ paying a dividend of 6 % or greater and all 199 Canadian common stocks paying a dividend of 3.5% or greater on the TSX. A scoring system objectively, mathematically applies a derived number to a stock. This number identifies those dividend stocks that will provide the most reliable, generous dividend income with the potential for substantial future share price gain. Continue Reading…