Debt & Frugality

As Didi says in the novel (Findependence Day), “There’s no point climbing the Tower of Wealth when you’re still mired in the basement of debt.” If you owe credit-card debt still charging an usurous 20% per annum, forget about building wealth: focus on eliminating that debt. And once done, focus on paying off your mortgage. As Theo says in the novel, “The foundation of financial independence is a paid-for house.”

Master your Mortgage for Financial Freedom

Posted By |

 

“</p

By Michael J. Wiener

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Many people have heard of the Smith Manoeuvre, which is a way to borrow against the equity in your home to invest and take a tax deduction for the interest on the borrowed money.

It was originally popularized by the late Fraser Smith, who passed away in September 2011.  Now his son, Robinson Smith, has written the book Master Your Mortgage for Financial Freedom, which covers the Smith Manoeuvre in detail for more modern times.  Smith Jr. explains the Manoeuvre and its subtleties well, but his characterization of its benefits is misleading in places.

The Smith Manoeuvre

In Canada, you can only deduct interest payments on your taxes if you invest the borrowed money in a way that has a reasonable expectation of earning income.  Buying a house does not have the expectation of earning income, so you can’t deduct the interest portion of your mortgage payments.

However, if you have enough equity in your home that a lender is willing to let you borrow more money, you could invest this borrowed money in a non-registered account and deduct the interest on this new loan on your income taxes (as long as you follow CRA’s rules carefully).  A common mistake would be to spend some of the invested money or spend some of the borrowed money.  If you do this, then some of the money you borrowed is no longer borrowed for the purpose of investing to earn income.  So, you would lose some of your tax deduction.

With each mortgage payment, you pay down some of the principal of your mortgage, and assuming the lender was happy with your original mortgage size, you can re-borrow the equity you just paid down for the purpose of investing and deducting any interest on this new loan.  Some lenders offer mortgage products with two parts: the first is a standard mortgage, and the second is a line of credit (LOC) whose limit automatically adjusts so that the amount you still owe on your standard mortgage plus the LOC limit stays constant.  So, after each standard mortgage payment, your LOC limit goes up by the amount of mortgage principal you just paid, and you can re-borrow this amount to invest and deduct LOC interest on your taxes.  This is the Smith Manoeuvre.

Smith describes a number of ways of paying off your mortgage principal faster (that he calls “accelerators”) so that you can borrow against the new principal sooner and boost your tax deductions.

Compared to a Standard Mortgage Plan

Ordinarily, mortgagors pay off their mortgages slowly over many years.  Their risk of losing their home because of financial problems is highest initially when they owe the most.  This risk declines as the mortgage balance declines, and inflation reduces the effective debt size even further.

With the Smith Manoeuvre, the total amount you owe remains constant (declining mortgage balance plus LOC balance) or may even increase as your house value increases and your lender is willing to lend you more money against your house.  So, your risk level as a function of how much you owe doesn’t decline in the same way as it does with the standard mortgage plan.  You could argue that your financial risk does decline somewhat because you’ve got your invested savings to fall back on in hard times, but your risk certainly doesn’t decline as fast as it does with the standard plan.

Leveraged Investing

Smith likes to say that the Smith Manoeuvre isn’t a leveraged investment plan.  He justifies this assertion by saying that you’ve already borrowed to buy your home, and you’re now slowly converting this mortgage that isn’t tax deductible to an LOC debt that is tax deductible. Continue Reading…

6 things you can do to stay out of Debt

Posted By |

By Sia Hasan

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

No one wants to be in debt, but the good news is that you don’t have to be if you make smart financial decisions. Here are six ways you can change your habits and stay out of debt.

Create a monthly budget

Creating a monthly budget can help you visualize how much money you have coming in and how much typically goes toward expenses such as electricity, Internet and maintenance. There are plenty of apps that can help you get started, or you can go the old-fashioned route and use a pencil and paper. After about a month, you’ll be able to see how you can cut down on your expenses, such as canceling subscriptions that you don’t need or use.

Go Green

Not only can you go green on a budget, but it can actually save you money in the process. The next time you’re low on food, try going to the local farmers market instead of the grocery store. Contrary to popular belief, one study found that farmers markets are 10 to 20% less expensive than grocery stores. While you’re at it, bring your own reusable bag with you when shopping. Some stores will give you a refund, which can add up to $10 of savings a week. If you’re looking for another way to go green, installing solar panels in your home can be a great way to help the environment and save money at the same time. Although the initial investment may be large, you’ll actually end up cutting electrical costs in the long run. One study found that you can save up to $30,000 in the first 20 years after installing solar panels. If you’re interested in going solar, Loanpal can provide you with financing options.

Leave your credit cards at home

Unlike a credit card, you can’t overspend cash once it’s gone. Before you go on your next trip to the grocery store, bring only the amount of money that you think you’ll need. This way, you can stick to your list and you won’t be tempted to buy any extra treats or unnecessary items. Credit cards can make it difficult to know how much you’re actually spending, which can lead to costs rapidly accumulating. Continue Reading…

Retired Money: What can retirees do about GIC reinvestment sticker shock?

Posted By |

My latest MoneySense Retired Money column looks at the vexing problem retirees and near-retirees face when their GICs have matured in recent months. Click on the highlighted text for the full column: Recovering from GIC sticker shock.

If before you were getting 2 to 3% on 2, 3, 4 or 5-year GICs, you may be shocked to discover you’ll be lucky to get 1% and only then by declining to take the first suggested GIC your brokerage has on offer. Going out 5 years may only gain you 0.5% or so, depending on provider.

Nor will matters improve any time soon. The Federal Reserve, Bank of Canada and other central banks have suggested interest rates will stay “lower for longer.” The Fed in particular has indicated rates are unlikely to rise for at least three years.

The piece passes on the views of financial advisors Adrian Mastracci and Matthew Ardrey on what to do about it. It amounts to grinning and bearing it and settling for lower guaranteed returns, or biting the bullet and taking a bit more risk with equities or alternative investments.

But what if you insist on what our family has done historically: leaving half your fixed-income allocation in GICs? Personally, I aim for roughly a 50/50 asset allocation and for the fixed-income portion historically have split it between laddered GICs and bond ETFs, or asset allocation ETFs with a healthy dose of bonds.

Odds are if you use the major discount brokerages of the big banks, you may need to leave them to find more generous GICs available from independent places like Oaken Financial, which has a 1-year registered GIC paying 1.4% and a 5-year GIC currently paying 2% through Home Trust and Home Equity Bank.

Personally, I have reinvested some GIC cash in 2- or 3-year maturities, on the hope rates start to rise three years from now. While 1% or so is pathetic at least it’s a positive number (ignoring inflation): with so many mentions of negative interest rates in Europe and sometimes floated by central bankers in North America, any positive return at is not to be sneezed at.

Conservative Asset Allocation ETFs are one possible alternative

Among the gambits I’ve tried is to raise risk slightly by moving some of this cash to ETFs like Vanguard’s Conservative Income ETF Portfolio [VCIP/TSX], which is 80% fixed income but provides a modest 20% equity kicker. Those who don’t wish to mess with their pre-existing asset allocation might consider the Vanguard Global Bond ETF [VGAB], roughly split between US and global bonds, all hedged back into the Canadian dollar. Continue Reading…

Top 10 tips on becoming Financially Independent (or “Findependent”)

Posted By |

Financial independence is something for which everyone strives. But most of us never get to a stage of financial independence by choice and we reach this stage when we are very old and can no longer work anymore. And although it is not easy to achieve financial independence (aka “Findependence,”) it can be done if you know how to manage your money effectively.

1.) Develop a budget

The first thing that you need to do when you are trying to save money is to develop a budget. To develop a budget, you need to start by figuring out how much money you need to live on each month and then giving yourself an appropriate amount of money to use over the course of the month.

2.) Get a financial planner

If you have had trouble managing your finances in the past, you should consult a financial planner so that you can get the most out of your money. He or she can help you to plan out what you need to spend, so you will be able to figure out how much money you need to save in order to get where you want to be financially.

3.) Create financial goals

Setting financial goals ensures success, because it helps you to get a sense of what you want to achieve and where you want to go on your financial journey. Giving yourself short term and long term goals is usually the most effective way to achieve financial goals, because it allows you to plan and amend your plans as you go.

4.) Pay off your debts

If you have a lot of debt looming over your head, you should make sure that you pay it off before you start actively trying to save. Start by paying off your smaller debts that have the highest interest rate first, so that you won’t have to pay so much later on when the debt has increased.

5.) Get rid of student loans

When most people think of paying off their debts, they forget about paying off their student loans because they are a different kind of debt to your standard credit card debt or loan repayment. There are a few different options when it comes to repaying your student loan, from paying a fixed amount each week, to contributing a percentage of your average income every pay-day. Continue Reading…

A good resolution for 2021: Choose Financial Independence

Posted By |
Amazon.com

By Michael J. Wiener

Special to the Financial Independence Hub

Many of us dream of financial independence.  Chris Mamula, Brad Barrett, and Jonathan Mendonsa offer many practical ideas for achieving financial independence (FI) and enjoying the journey along the way in their book Choose FI: Your Blueprint to Financial Independence.  They avoid many of the problems we see in the FIRE (Financial Independence Retire Early) book category.

The authors avoid the biggest problem with most FIRE books.  It’s annoying to tell the story of a high-income earner deciding to live like a student his whole life and retire in his 30s, and then say “you can too!”  Although I point out the bad parts of books, I can forgive a lot if my mind is opened to a good idea.  For this reason, I’ve enjoyed FIRE books even if they have some bad parts.  This book manages to avoid the worst parts of other FIRE books.

The authors don’t bother much with retirement.  FI gives us choices so we can “scrap the idea of retirement completely and focus on building lives we don’t want to retire from.”  The life you build can involve paid work, leisure, or any other pursuit you want.

Rather than focus on just one story, the authors draw from the experience of many people who have sought FI.  A common theme is the importance of enjoying the journey.  If you see your pursuit of FI as suffering for several years until you hit your magic number, you’re not doing it the right way.

FI’s benefits start even before you reach the target

You benefit from pursuing FI even before you reach your target.  “If you have a mortgage, a couple car payments, a family to feed, and nothing in the bank, what choice do you have when your boss asks you to do something stupid?”  I was able to push back somewhat with my boss in the late part of my career, and this got me more money and autonomy.

If reaching FI seems like an unattainable goal, it may help to break it down into milestones.  The authors suggest “getting to zero” for those in debt, “fully funded emergency fund,” “hitting six figures” in your portfolio, “half FI,” “getting close,” “FI,” and “FI with cushion.”  This last stage is defined as having a portfolio equal to 33 times your annual spending needs.  This is a sensible target for a young person with a long remaining life who doesn’t really know how spending needs will change with age. Continue Reading…